Following a vote by the conference's ten head coaches, the Liberty League has announced the 2025 Women's Soccer Major Awards and All-League teams.
PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Ruth Hotaling, Senior, Midfielder, William Smith College
For the second time in three years, a William Smith soccer player has been named Liberty League Player of the Year. Senior midfielder Ruth Hotaling earns the 2025 honor after leading the Herons’ offense this season. Hotaling started all 17 games in midfield and led both the team and the conference with 12 goals and 25 points. She also paced the league in goals per game (.706), points per game (1.47), shots on goal (26), and shots on goal per game (1.53). Hotaling recorded four game-winning goals, ranking second in the Liberty League, and contributed to a stingy William Smith defense that posted 10 shutouts in 17 games while allowing just 13 goals (.764 per game). Against conference opponents, she totaled a league-best eight goals and 17 points in nine games, helping the Herons secure five shutouts while conceding only seven goals. A four-year starter, Hotaling finishes her career with 83 games played, while scoring 26 goals and handing out 25 assists for a total of 76 points.
DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Katrina Varnum, Sophomore, Goalkeeper, Ithaca College
For the first time in program history, an Ithaca soccer player was recognized as the Liberty League Defensive Player of the Year, with sophomore goalkeeper Katrina Varnum receiving the 2025 distinction. After seeing just 28 minutes of action in 2024, Varnum had a breakout sophomore season, starting all 18 games and totaling 1,594 minutes in goal. She compiled an overall record of 8-6-4 and finished the year with a league-best .452 goals-against average, .895 save percentage, and nine shutouts, while ranking fourth in total saves (68) and sixth in saves per game (3.78). Nationally, Varnum is 16th in save percentage, 20th in goals-against average, and tied for 22nd in total shutouts. In two Liberty League tournament games, she made 12 saves, recorded one shutout, and allowed just one goal as the fifth-seeded Bombers advanced to at least the Liberty League semifinals for the fifth consecutive year.
ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Ava Holman, Forward, Vassar
For the second consecutive year, a Vassar first-year has been selected as the Liberty League Rookie of the Year, with Ava Holman garnering the 2025 accolade. Holman made an immediate impact with the Brewers, appearing in all 19 games (6 starts) and leading the team with 23 points, thanks to 10 goals and three assists. She ranked among the league’s top three in multiple categories, including game-winning goals (T-1st, 5), points (2nd), goals (2nd), and shots on goal (T-2nd, 25). A five-time Liberty League Rookie of the Week selection, Holman notched a pair of goals in three games and recorded three or more points on four occasions. She scored the lone goal in the 2025 Liberty League title match, leading the Brewers to their first-ever Liberty League Championship with a 1-0 victory.
COACHING STAFF OF THE YEAR: Vassar College – Keith Simons, Head Coach; Assistant Coaches Marissa Fortuna, Sarah Dwyer-Shick, and Adam Pregno
Vassar head coach Keith Simons and his assistant coaches were named Liberty League Coaching Staff of the Year after guiding the Brewers to a 16-3-0 overall record and an 8-1-0 mark in league play. Vassar secured the top seed in the Liberty League tournament and captured the regular season title for the first time in program history. In the tournament, the Brewers posted back-to-back 1-0 victories to claim the program’s first-ever league crown. The team also set a program record for wins this season, surpassing the previous mark of 13 set in 1995. As a team, Vassar leads the league with 2.63 goals per game, 1.89 assists per game, and 7.16 points per game. Defensively, the Brewers have allowed just 13 goals while recording a league-high 11 shutouts. Vassar now moves on to the NCAA Championship, where the Brewers will face University of Mary Washington in the first round on November 15.